top of page

Supporting an LPA Donor to Make Decisions: Keeping Their Voice Central

Writer: Hashim Ahmed, LLB (Hons), FNALP
Hashim Ahmed, LLB (Hons), FNALP
Oct 30
6 min read

Updated: Nov 7

Supporting an LPA donor to make decisions starts with a simple question: what help would let this person decide for themselves? A registered lasting power of attorney is an important safeguard, but it does not turn every conversation into an attorney's decision. The person who made it remains at the centre of the arrangement.


This guide concerns existing LPAs under the England and Wales framework. It focuses on everyday communication and practical support after the document has been made, rather than the separate question of whether someone has capacity to create an LPA. The examples are suggestions for organising a conversation, not individual capacity findings.


Reading glasses on an open notebook beside a laptop and pen

Supporting an LPA donor to make decisions: start with the particular choice


Avoid beginning with a sweeping question such as whether someone can manage their whole life. Identify the actual decision: choosing a meal, agreeing a household purchase, changing a service or deciding where to live. Different choices involve different information and consequences. A difficulty with one task does not answer every other question.


For a practical starting note, write down the decision in one sentence. Then list what genuinely needs explaining. For a repair, that might include the problem, available options, likely cost and what happens if nothing is done. Keep unrelated concerns out of the first conversation so the person is not trying to answer several questions at once.


Begin with the legal principles


The Mental Capacity Act 2005 principles require capacity to be presumed unless lack of capacity is established. All practicable steps to help someone decide must be tried without success before treating them as unable to decide. An unwise decision alone is not enough. These principles apply even when relatives feel anxious.


This means a rushed conversation is a poor starting point. If someone did not hear the question, could not read the document or was overwhelmed by unfamiliar language, first address that difficulty. The goal is to give them a fair opportunity to engage with the information. Agreement with the attorney is not the measure of success.


Separate making a decision from carrying it out


A person may know what they want but struggle to complete an online form, hold a pen or wait on a telephone line. Those practical barriers should be identified accurately. Ask whether the person needs information, physical assistance, communication support or someone authorised to carry out an agreed task. These are different kinds of help.


For example, a donor may choose which routine household service they want after comparing clear information, then ask for assistance contacting the provider. Record their choice and what assistance they requested. Do not describe the decision as yours simply because you typed the answer. Equally, do not use the donor's login or signature as a shortcut around an organisation's proper authority checks.


Check which LPA applies before acting


A property and financial affairs attorney may act while the donor has capacity only where the LPA permits this and the donor gives permission. The government's financial attorney guidance explains that distinction. Read the document's instructions and appointment arrangements before assuming that registration alone authorises a particular transaction.


A health and welfare attorney can make a decision only when the donor lacks capacity to make that decision. The health and welfare guidance describes this limit. An attorney can still help someone understand information and communicate their wishes without taking over a choice the donor can make. Medical teams also have their own responsibilities.


Ask what makes communication easier


A useful conversation begins by asking the person how they prefer to receive information. They may want a short written explanation to read privately, a discussion without interruptions or enough time to consider the options before replying. Offer help in a way that preserves dignity. Avoid turning ordinary preferences into a test the person feels they must pass.


Check practical details before the discussion: whether glasses or hearing aids are available, whether the room is comfortable and whether an interpreter or other communication support is needed. Ask one question at a time. If a document contains technical words, explain them plainly and invite questions. Do not overwhelm the person with every possible future scenario in one sitting.


Present options without steering the answer


A clear comparison is often more useful than repeatedly asking for agreement. Put the realistic options side by side using the same kinds of information for each. If you explain the cost of one option, explain the cost of the others too. Include the option of doing nothing where it is genuinely available, with the relevant consequences.


Notice how the question is framed. Asking which option the person prefers leaves more space than announcing the choice you have already made and asking them to confirm it. Avoid recruiting several relatives to persuade the donor. A supportive conversation gives the person room to disagree, ask for clarification or say that they need more information.


Allow time and revisit practical obstacles


Plan discussions around the person's needs rather than the most convenient time for everybody else. If they are tired, distressed or interrupted, consider whether a non-urgent conversation can take place in better circumstances. Record the actual deadline if there is one, so a genuine time limit can be distinguished from family impatience.


A short second conversation may answer a practical question that remained unclear the first time. For example, obtain the missing quotation or ask the provider to explain a charge before returning to the options. This is not an instruction to keep asking until the donor gives your preferred answer. Repetition should clarify information, not wear down resistance.


What if you think the choice is unwise?


A disagreement may reveal different priorities rather than inability to decide. The donor may value familiarity, privacy or a particular routine more than a relative does. Ask what matters to them and listen to the explanation. Avoid treating age, diagnosis or a decision you dislike as a substitute for considering the actual circumstances.


You can raise a genuine concern respectfully and supply relevant information without claiming a power to override the person. If there are substantial doubts about decision-making ability, coercion or the consequences of a major transaction, seek appropriate professional advice. Do not improvise a capacity verdict to resolve a family argument or move a transaction forward.


Keep the donor involved if you must decide


Where the donor lacks capacity for the relevant decision and you have authority to act, their involvement still matters. Section 4 of the Mental Capacity Act requires attention to participation, wishes, feelings, beliefs and values within the best-interests process. It also requires consideration of whether the person is likely to regain capacity.


Practical involvement can be modest but meaningful. Explain what is being considered, ask what they like or dislike and listen to any clear preferences. Avoid talking over them simply because other people are present. A person who cannot weigh every aspect of a complex decision may still express something important about their comfort, relationships or everyday life.


Write a brief note that shows whose decision it was


A useful working note identifies the choice, date, information discussed and help provided. Record the donor's own preference accurately, including any question left unanswered. If they made the decision, say so. If you made a decision under the LPA, distinguish that from assistance with communication or administration and record the basis of your authority.


Keep the note proportionate. A routine practical discussion does not need to become a lengthy report. For a significant decision, retain relevant advice and the reasons for the eventual choice. The OPG's property and finances attorney guide provides a fuller explanation of the role. Store personal information securely and share it only where appropriate.


Prepare relatives and organisations for the conversation


Before an appointment, tell the organisation what communication support the donor would find helpful. Ask for the main questions or relevant papers in advance where possible. Explain whether the donor intends to speak for themselves and what role you will have. This can reduce the risk of the discussion being directed entirely towards the attorney.


If several relatives attend, agree who will provide practical assistance and leave space for the donor to answer. Do not present a family consensus as though it were the donor's instructions. Where a private conversation is appropriate, support that opportunity. Clear roles make it easier to see which points came from the donor and which are someone else's observations.


Make the next conversation more useful


Before the next decision, prepare a short list: what needs deciding, what information is missing, how the donor wants it explained and whether any action needs attorney authority. Afterwards, check that the agreed next step is understood. A small amount of preparation can make the discussion calmer and prevent unnecessary assumptions.


H.A. Law Advisory's lasting power of attorney support can help people in England consider how their proposed arrangements will work in practice. Complex capacity disputes, suspected abuse and Court of Protection proceedings require appropriate specialist advice. This article is general information; the actual LPA and the particular decision must always be considered.


Comments


Tel: 02074 323870
Email: hashim@halawadvisory.com 
London.
​
© 2026 H.A. Law Advisory. All rights reserved.
Hashim Ahmed, LLB (Hons), FNALP | Licensed Paralegal Practitioner​

bottom of page